Modula vs Envira Gallery – Which Is The Best WordPress Gallery Plugin?


WordPress Deals

Trying to choose between Modula vs Envira Gallery to create a gallery on your WordPress site?

If you search for the best WordPress gallery plugins, these are two of the first names you’ll encounter. Both are popular and highly rated — Modula with a 4.7-star rating on over 340 reviews and Envira Gallery with a 4.8-star rating on over 1,370 reviews (both according to WordPress.org).

So — how can you choose the right gallery plugin for your needs?

Well, that’s the goal of this post. By going hands-on with both plugins and comparing them in a number of key areas, I aim to help you understand the key similarities and differences between these two plugins. Here are the six areas that I’ll compare them on:

  1. Features
  2. Interfaces
  3. Gallery layout options
  4. Gallery content sources
  5. Pricing
  6. Performance

In general, both plugins are excellent options, but I think they have slightly different focuses. Modula is a better option for casual users such as bloggers, while Envira Gallery is a better option for heavy-duty users such as photographers or users who want to go beyond just images and video in their galleries (such as creating a gallery of WooCommerce products).

To learn where my conclusions come from, keep reading the full comparison!

Let’s kick things off with some basic introductions…

Modula

The Modula homepage

Modula is a WordPress gallery plugin from WP Chill, the same team behind the Kali Forms and Strong Testimonials plugins.

Modula focuses mainly on creating great-looking WordPress image and video galleries for regular WordPress users. For example, if you’re a travel blogger and you want to create a gallery of your travel images, Modula is aimed at you.

This is my personal opinion — but I think you can see the evidence of this focus as I compare the plugins.

According to WordPress.org, Modula is active on 90,000+ sites with a 4.7-star rating on 340 reviews, including 293 five-star reviews.

The Envira Gallery homepage

Envira Gallery originally got its start as part of Syed Balkhi’s WPBeginner empire of plugins, which includes other big names such as WPForms, OptinMonster, MonsterInsights, and more.

However, it was sold to a new owner (Nathan Singh) in early 2018. Nathan also went on to acquire the popular NextGEN Gallery plugin in early 2020, so Envira Gallery and NextGEN Gallery are now under the same roof and the current owner is definitely the biggest player in the WordPress gallery plugin space.

Envira Gallery can make a great option for both casual users and advanced users. However, you’ll see that it’s a little more focused on photographers and power users via features such as image proofing (for working with clients), eCommerce support, an Adobe Lightroom integration, and more.

Again, this is my personal opinion, but I think you’ll see this focus played out in the features.

According to WordPress.org, Envira Gallery is active on 100,000+ sites with a 4.8-star rating on 1,374 reviews, including 1,242 five-star reviews.

Comparing Features

In this section, I just want to do a quick comparison table-style rundown of each plugin’s features so that you can get a basic understanding of how they compare at a high-level.

Overall, you can see that Envira Gallery is a little ahead in terms of the number of features that it has, especially when it comes to advanced features such as eCommerce support and client proofing.

However, Modula also has some unique tricks up its sleeve, such as its custom grid builder, which I’ll show you later on.

Modula Envira Gallery
Image galleries ✔️ ✔️
Video galleries ✔️ ✔️
WordPress content galleries (posts, products, etc.) ✔️
Grid galleries ✔️ ✔️
Masonry galleries ✔️ ✔️
Slider galleries ✔️ ✔️
Custom grid builder ✔️
Lightbox popup ✔️ ✔️
Hover effects ✔️ ✔️
Albums ✔️ ✔️
Ajax gallery filters ✔️ ✔️
Deeplinking for SEO ✔️ ✔️
Watermarking ✔️ ✔️
Password protect galleries ✔️ ✔️
Instagram import ✔️
Adobe Lightroom integration ✔️
Client proofing ✔️
eCommerce integration ✔️
Social share buttons ✔️ ✔️
Image downloads ✔️ ✔️
Right-click protection ✔️ ✔️
Lazy loading ✔️ ✔️
Image optimization ✔️
Scheduling ✔️

Note — many of these features require the premium versions of both plugins.

Comparing Interfaces

In this section, I’m going to compare the basic process of creating a gallery with each plugin. This should help you understand the core user experience in each plugin.

Overall, both plugins are fairly similar, so there isn’t a clear winner in either direction. You should have no issues no matter which gallery plugin you choose.

Modula

When you create a gallery with Modula, you’ll see an interface that looks a lot like the classic WordPress content editor.

You’ll get a “content editor” at the top to control your gallery content and then a Settings box below to control its functionality. To rearrange images, you can just drag-and-drop them:

Modula’s gallery builder interface

The settings area is divided into a bunch of different options. You may or may not have access to every single option depending on your license and the add-ons that you’ve installed, but you can see the full list of potential settings below:

The many gallery settings that Modula gives you

Once you’re happy with your gallery, you can embed your gallery using a shortcode or block. One nice thing about the embeds is that you get two options:

  1. You can embed the gallery directly.
  2. You can display a link that visitors can click to open the gallery (kind of like a two-step opt-in).

Envira Gallery uses the same basic approach to its gallery creation interface.

At the top, you can choose the source for your gallery content (more on that later). Once you choose the content, you’ll see the images appear in the Gallery tab of the meta box. You can also use the other tabs to configure how your gallery works (you’ll get access to more tabs if you install the premium add-ons):

Envira Gallery’s gallery builder interface

To embed your gallery, you get the same options as Modula. That is, you can use a shortcode or block and you can also choose between embedding the gallery directly or adding a button that opens the gallery.

Next, let’s look at the types of gallery layouts each plugin lets you create. Overall, Envira Gallery gives you slightly more flexibility in terms of built-in gallery layouts, but I give the edge to Modula because of its custom grid builder.

Modula

Modula comes with four gallery types:

  • Creative Gallery — an automatically-generated masonry-style gallery.
  • Columns — a straightforward grid/column layout.
  • Custom Grid — I’ll highlight this below — you can build your own custom grid using a drag-and-drop builder.
  • Slider — convert your gallery into a slider.

You also get built-in lightbox gallery support and album support.

Modula’s most unique layout option is its custom grid builder, which I personally think is awesome. With the custom grid builder, you can use a simple drag-and-drop interface to control the actual grid that your gallery uses:

Modula’s custom grid builder lets you use drag-and-drop to control your gallery’s layout

I love it because it gives you pixel-perfect control over your gallery, rather than relying on the automatic masonry generation.

It’s the same grid builder from the less-popular Gallery PhotoBlocks plugin, which WP Chill (Modula’s developer) acquired a while back and then merged into Modula.

You can check out some demos of the galleries here.

Envira Gallery comes with five built-in gallery layouts:

  • Automatic — a justified image grid.
  • Mason — a masonry gallery.
  • Grid — a straightforward column gallery.
  • Square — a sort of Instagram-style gallery.
  • Blogroll — lists your images one-by-one.
Envira Gallery’s five gallery layout options — you can see a simple preview of how each looks

You also get built-in lightbox galleries, as well as album support.

Overall, you get all the important gallery layout types, but you don’t get the custom grid builder that Modula offers. 

You can check out demos of the different galleries here.

Most people use gallery plugins to create image galleries. So if you just want to create a gallery from images that you upload to your site, there’s no difference between these two plugins.

But if you want to create a gallery from other content sources, Envira Gallery is more flexible than Modula.

Modula

Modula lets you create unlimited image galleries in the free version. Then, if you upgrade to the premium version, you can also create video galleries.

Those two content sources alone should cover most use cases, but that’s all you get with Modula.

Envira Gallery is a lot more flexible than Modula when it comes to content sources. Like Modula, Envira Gallery gives you images in the free version and videos in the premium version. But then the premium version also goes a lot further…

First off, with the Featured Content add-on, you can create galleries to feature WordPress content by pulling in the content from any WordPress post type. This lets you use a gallery to feature your latest blog posts, WooCommerce products, testimonials, projects, etc. — you can check out a demo here.

Second, Envira Gallery also includes tools to help you import gallery items from third-party sources. For example, you can import Instagram images to your gallery or sync your gallery with a folder on Dropbox. 

If you’re a photographer, you’ll also like that you’re able to sync your gallery with Adobe Lightroom.

Finally, with the Dynamic add-on, Envira Gallery also lets you create galleries on-the-fly by automatically populating a gallery with the images that are attached to a post.

If you’re just creating simple image or video galleries, all these extra bells and whistles might not matter. But for power users, you might appreciate the flexibility that Envira Gallery offers here.

Comparing Pricing

Modula and Envira Gallery both operate on a freemium model. You can find free versions of both plugins at WordPress.org as well as premium versions with more features.

For their premium versions, both plugins use an “add-on” model, with different add-ons available to you depending on the plan that you choose.

Modula Pricing

Modula’s premium plans start at $34 and range up to $124 for one year of support and updates. After the first year, you can continue using the plugin but you’ll need to renew your license if you want to keep getting support and updates.

You can see which features the plans have in the comparison table below:

Modula’s pricing and a feature comparison table

Envira Gallery’s premium plans initially start at $14 and range up to $49 for the one-year license. Or, you can pay $269 for a lifetime license on unlimited sites.

I can’t fit the full comparison table into the screenshot, but you can view it if you go to the pricing page:

Envira Gallery’s pricing and a partial look at the feature comparison table

One key thing to understand with Envira Gallery’s non-lifetime pricing is that the price in the screenshot above only applies to your first year. If you want to renew your license after the first year to continue receiving support/updates, you’ll need to pay “full price”, which is the crossed-out number above the price in the screenshot above.

Comparing Performance

Performance optimization should be a key factor in every single WordPress plugin you choose to use on your site. With that in mind, this section is focused on whether Modula or Envira Gallery is better-suited to help you get a fast-loading WordPress site.

To test this, I set up an identical gallery using each plugin and ran it through Pingdom to see what’s happening in terms of the page size and HTTP requests. I used the same theme — GeneratePress — and identical settings for the galleries.

The results? Both plugins are virtually identical in terms of performance. 

My test site using Envira Gallery had one fewer HTTP request — 22 requests vs 23 for the Modula site. Envira Gallery was also a few KB smaller (5.3 KB, to be exact). Honestly, those differences are just nitpicking and there’s pretty much zero performance difference between these two plugins.

Modula Envira Gallery
HTTP Requests 23 22
JavaScript Size 90.1 KB 95.8 KB
CSS Size 41.8 KB 29.5 KB
HTML Size 9.4 KB 10.7 KB
Total Non-Image Page Size 141.3 KB 136 KB

Note — all of these numbers include GeneratePress — the HTTP requests and code sizes are not just from the plugins.

Here are the full breakdowns — you can see that the image size is identical because I used the exact same images…

Modula:

Modula performance analysis

Envira Gallery:

Envira Gallery performance analysis

How to Improve the Performance of Both Plugins

I tested both plugins in their default state, but both plugins also give you features to help you further improve the performance of your galleries.

For example, both Modula and Envira Gallery have built-in lazy loading features. I didn’t enable these for the initial tests, but they would make a big improvement by waiting to load your gallery’s images/videos until a user scrolled to the point of interacting with the gallery.

Modula also includes a unique built-in content delivery network (CDN) feature on its Trio plan and above. This feature, available via the Speed Up add-on, lets you optimize your gallery images using ShortPixel’s algorithms and then serve them up via StackPath’s global CDN.

This is definitely a nice feature to have…but I think you’d be better off implementing this at the site level for all of your images, rather than just your gallery images. To that end, you could achieve something similar by just using the ShortPixel plugin and then setting up a CDN for all your images. You could use StackPath, KeyCDN, Bunny CDN, or other CDN networks. Or, you could use ShortPixel’s Adaptive Images plugin or Optimole.

Overall, I don’t think there’s one clear winner when it comes to Modula vs Envira Gallery. Instead, it really just depends on what you’re looking for in a WordPress gallery plugin.

In general, I would say that Modula is the slightly better option for casual users who just want to create image or video galleries. I mainly prefer Modula for this use case because of its custom grid builder, as I find that to be a really nice feature for basic gallery usage. Envira Gallery can also get the job done, though, so I don’t think the difference is huge for this casual use case.

On the other hand, I think Envira Gallery is definitely a better option for photographers or other heavy-duty users. Or, it’s also a better option if you want to go beyond basic image or video galleries (such as creating a gallery of your WooCommerce products or blog posts).

For photographers and heavy-duty users, Envira Gallery just plain has useful features that Modula doesn’t have:

  • Client proofing — great if you’re a photographer who needs to share images with clients.
  • eCommerce support — you can sell images. Pair this with client proofing and you get a solution where clients can proof the photos and then immediately purchase the images that they want.
  • Adobe Lightroom integration — sync your Lightroom workflows with your gallery.

Envira Gallery is also a lot more flexible when it comes to dynamically-sourced galleries, letting you create galleries from WordPress posts, WooCommerce products, Instagram, a Dropbox folder, and more.

Both plugins are high-quality tools, so it’s really just about choosing the option that best fits your needs.

Used/using Modula or Envira Gallery? Thoughts?

Colin Newcomer is a freelance writer and long-time Internet marketer. He specializes in digital marketing and WordPress. He lives a life of danger, riding a scooter through the chaos of Hanoi.



Source link

Leave a Comment